Watched this last night for the 6th or 7th time. It's still a riot. Some commentary:
What's Up Doc? (1972)
This has been one of my favorite comedies since first watching it in the theater in 1972. It's one of those films in which the laughs keep coming, oftentimes piling up to where one is forced to catch a breath.
Preceded by
The Last Picture Show, and followed by
Paper Moon, all great films, Peter Bogdanovich was on a roll. He has done many comedies, but to my knowledge "Doc" is his only "screwball" comedy. And screwball it is. The story involves the misplacement and confusion over four identical plaid suitcases, one of which contains some type of government secret documents; another one holds stolen jewels. The others belong to the two leads.
Everyone gets their suitcase shuffled around, which leads to an explosive exposition in a San Francisco hotel. Along the way there is scene after scene of sight gags, pratfalls, and absurdities, which take the characters through Chinatown, down San Fransisco's steep streets, including the famous Lombard Street, and even into San Fransisco Bay. The film is nicely woven together and finishes up with a perfect ending.
Being a romantic comedy, the two leads --Barbara Streisand and Ryan O'Neal-- are not called upon for dramatic heft. But sharp timing and chemistry are required, and delivered. Both stars were at the period in their lives where they were very attractive and appealing, and they film beautifully. Both are successful at comedy, with Streisand showing a broader palette.
But it is the writing and the supporting cast who fashion this picture into a comedic farce which steams along, maintaining a full tilt pace for all of its 94 minutes. Bogdanovich's story is perfected by the inestimable Buck Henry along with David Newman and Robert Benton, who all won the Writer's Guild of America Award for this film.
Madeline Kahn, as O'Neal's stodgy wife Eunice Burns was nominated for a Golden Globe. The cast was peppered with strong talent: Kenneth Mars as an effete conceited slavic musicologist was an integral part of the script. Other comic heavyweights were John Hillerman, Randy Quaid, and Austin Pendleton. The venerable Liam Dunn played a judge, and even M. Emmett Walsh did a turn as an arresting officer. This was a dream cast.
This movie fired on all burners. It was hilarious, suggestive and sexy-- all within a "G" rating. If only more films like this one could be made!
Doc's rating: 10/10